Rylan will sing again next week
Carolynne Poole became the first person to be voted off The X Factor last night.
The judge had initially chosen to save Carolynne, 32, but changed his mind after host Dermot O’Leary asked him to confirm his choice.
Rylan, 23, had received the most votes from the public – meaning Carolynne had to go home.
Her furious mentor Gary, 41, stormed off the stage, calling the decision an ‘absolute joke’.
And some incensed viewers claimed the whole thing was a fix after spotting a producer whispering to Louis, 60, while Carolynne was still in the middle of her sing-off performance.
‘Producers always speak to judges at intermittent times throughout the show,’ says a spokesman.
‘Carolynne had the least public votes so the public’s choice to stay in the show was Rylan.’
SEE PICTURES Louis Tomlinson and One Direction sign copies of album Up All Night in New York
SEE PICTURES Louis Tomlinson with One Direction and red carpet guests at the Brits 2012
VIDEO: One Direction’s Harry Styles supports Cancer Research UK
VIDEO: One Direction coming soon
VIDEO: Teen Now meets One Direction part 1
VIDEO: Teen Now meets One Direction part 2
VIDEO: One Direction at Capital FM Jingle Bell Ball part 2